EPIPHANY 2
A New Inquisition
1 Corinthians 12.1 Concerning what you
wrote about the gifts of the Holy Spirit. I want you to know the truth
about them, my brothers.
A great scandal has arisen in
the Church. It has crept up quietly, noticed only by the most alert.
Other apparently more pressing matters have tended to obscure it. While
Christians agonise about homosexual bishops, child abuse, issues of
social justice, and war, a much more important and fundamental matter is being
largely ignored.
The scandal is the way teaching about the Holy Spirit is being used
to demonise and exclude some from the Christian fellowship.
Paul says almost nothing about the nature of the
Spirit. In fact, nowhere in his letters does he analyse who or what the
Spirit is. He merely explains the results or "fruits" of the
Spirit. These are the outpouring of love, peace, joy and guidance.
We are enabled to dedicate ourselves, our consciences are ruled and we
are energised and renewed. The Spirit is closely linked with fellowship
(2 Corinthians 13.13).
A detailed theology of the Spirit was not developed
until long after Paul's time. This theology contains certain assumptions
which are foreign to a large majority of ordinary people today. The most
important is that its proponents often claim that the Spirit
has led them to absolute truth - either via inspired scripture or by
some other revelation.
It follows that their hotline to God bestows a right and
duty to correct those perceived to be in the wrong. Some Christians feel
justified in condemning those who disagree with their teachings. And
those whose behaviour doesn't match the standards supposedly revealed by the Spirit
are likewise demonised.
The signs of a new-style inquisition are inescapable.
Homosexuals are vilified. Sexual deviants are hunted down and punished. Schism is threatened unless the will of the
inspired prevails. In the Church of England a tribunal to flush out
heretics has been proposed. Divorcees are excluded. Missionaries urge
those of other faiths to enter the
Christian fold or perish in the fires of hell.
In short, the fruits of
the "Spirit" are proving in practice to be dissension, division, hatred,
persecution and self-righteousness. These are not those to
which Paul referred.
Paul writes, "There are inspired messages, but they are
temporary ... there is knowledge, but it will pass" (1 Corinthians
13.8). Nothing is cast in concrete except love. Inquisitors fool
themselves if they think they have somehow grasped absolute truth. As
Paul put it, "What I know now is only partial" (13.12).
How can we think of the Spirit in the
21st-century?
Would-be inquisitors might revise their sense of absolute superiority
if they were to recognise that the Spirit is hidden from them. It's a still, small
voice in the wilderness (1 Kings 19.12). We see the dry bones being
clothed with flesh - the results or "fruits". But we don't see what or who gives them life
(Ezekiel 37).
Many today can't easily grasp the idea of "spirit" as some
sort of non-physical being or aspect of the Godhead. Such concepts came
more easily to a past age. But to us they frequently mean little or
nothing - that is, they become irrelevant to our daily lives.
Perhaps a better phrase to describe
the Spirit would be "life-force". In other words, people all through the ages in every country and
society have always seen and known the fruits of what Christians call
"the Spirit". They have seen its results in every renewal,
every urge to grow and develop, in the world's vast diversity. Every
revival from personal disaster, each turn from a destructive to a
productive way of life, every tiny or great movement of nature witnesses
to the Spirit.
The world's life-force is not and cannot be confined within any
formula, in any church, or by any government. It isn't a Christian
possession or monopoly. It can't be owned or even grasped. It can't be
described or defined. The work can be seen but not the worker.
The life-force which breathes into every fibre of our being, which
invigorates and revives the depths of the natural order cannot, thank
God, be imprisoned or killed by the new inquisitors.
We have good reason
to fear them, for they will often go to great lengths to force their
will on others. But there is no reason to suppose they will triumph.
[Home] [Back]
|