| Preaching
Two
stereotypes in the popular mind of the 21st century characterise the Christian Church. One is the
picture of a group of robed clerics clustered round an altar
participating in elaborate rituals and swathed in a cloud of incense.
The other is of a fiery preacher, haranguing a quaking or rejoicing
congregation from a pulpit or stage "six feet above
contradiction". The former
image is most closely connected with the Catholic party of the Christian
Church; the latter with the Protestant party. Yet both groups place
preaching at the heart of the Christian ministry. Preaching as a
ministry is not confined to the ordained. If the clergy don't do their
preaching, lay people must. The roots of preaching as an
activity go back far beyond the boundaries of human history. Our very
earliest evidence indicates an art already sophisticated and central to
even the most primitive cultures. Certainly by the time of the Greek
and Roman cultures the art of speaking (rhetoric) was an essential part
of a gentleman's education. Apuleius in the second century says that at
a banquet
The first cup is poured for us by the litterator who begins
to polish the roughness of our mind. Then comes the grammaticus
who adorns us with varied knowledge. Finally it is the rhetor's
turn, who puts in our hands the weapons of eloquence. [1]
Rhetoric as the art of persuasion was tuned to a fine pitch in the
Roman Empire and so on through into Europe of the very recent past. It
was equally prized in other cultures. The author of the Acts of the
Apostles (17.19) relates how Paul in Athens attempted to speak in the
public square where many a debate would have taken place. Paul's
preaching in Athens failed - but we don't know
if that was because he wasn't skilled enough or because his
hearers lacked interest in his subject. At any rate, Paul seems to
have been eloquent enough a speaker to persuade many in Corinth and
elsewhere to become Christian. He certainly was reputed to have talked
for a long time on occasion - in one case, long enough for the
unfortunate Eutychus to go to sleep and fall to his death out of a third
storey window (Acts 20.9). His letters clearly contain the message of
his sermons, no doubt preached over periods of time. But the length of
Paul's speech or sermon (as we would today term it) would not have been
unusual for the time. In Southern Africa today, many cultures are only a
generation away from a purely verbal means of communication. Paul's
culture, unlike those of Africa, had writing - though that was confined
to a very small proportion of the population. In both cases, the spoken
word was accorded a degree of respect much greater than that given by
the communication-overloaded cultures of modern times. To this day,
sermons in some African churches can last for hours, replete with
repetition and great detail. As scholars emphasise, the gospels are
essentially a type of preaching. That is, each contains a vision of
Jesus derived from a particular Christian region in the years between
about 70 (Mark) and about 110 (John). From the earliest days of the
Christian Church, then, preaching during gatherings and worship rapidly
became the norm - as it had been in Jewish communities and many other
places of (pagan) worship throughout the Roman world. In Roman political
life, the rhetorical debate took the place given today to the highly
professional image building of political parties through radio and
television. Over two millennia, the Church has gradually developed a
substantial practice of preaching. But expert preachers existed only in
the more educated strata of the clergy until quite recent times. In the
average congregation the sermon would have been more like an extended
homily than a well constructed, sophisticated sermon. In Europe
before the 17th century, for example, homilies were produced for the use
of poorly educated clergy. In 1547 a Book of Homilies was produced in
England for the use of disaffected and semi-literate clergy. It
consisted of twelve simple homilies, each about a theological or ethical
matter. A second book of twenty-one homilies followed in 1571. But it
was the Reformation which brought the sermon proper into full bloom. As
the new churches moved away from sacramental practices, so the art of
preaching the "Word of God" became more and more central. Just
as Catholic churches have the altar at the center of focus in a
building, so many Protestant churches placed the pulpit at the center. Preaching
as the proper function of a clergyman rose to its zenith as education
became more common. By the 19th century in the Western world, preaching
was important enough for many thousands of books of sermons to be
published and avidly collected and read by many. Today, preaching must
take its place in a world bombarded by political and commercial messages
through the media - from print to the most recent arrivals, the internet
and the mobile telephone.
Mass media preaching reaches millions wherever Christians are willing
and able to
pay the steep costs of buying television and radio time. Otherwise,
today's preachers speak to relatively small numbers as they gather in church for
worship. Nevertheless, there remains a sturdy body of
theory relating to preaching as an essential facet of the Christian
life. A typical outline might propose three aspects to preaching:
Exegesis It is the preacher's duty to expound a
biblical text from either the Old or the New Testament or, in the
case of the Catholic Church, an official church doctrine. The meaning
expounded should be that of those who first wrote the text or who
originally experienced the Word of God in their trailblazing
situation.
Interpretation The next step is to ensure that the
original meaning is translated into the concepts and terms of those
who are listening to the sermon. The underlying understanding is
that the original meaning is not bound by culture but is in a real
sense eternally applicable to all people everywhere.
Application The final step is for the
preacher to relate the message to the contemporary situation of his
hearers. How are they to apply what they hear in a culture which is
very different from that in which God first revealed his will?
Perhaps understandably, as the media have taken over the attention of
the average Western citizen, so have Christian claims for preaching
grown larger. In many churches, only the foolish preacher will time his
services and sermons to coincide with a popular television program or an
important sporting event. To compensate, many clergy insist that the
sermon remains more important than the mass media. And as the pews
have emptied in Europe, so have trainee clergy been given ever more
grounding in the practices of preaching in the wake of far reaching
theological claims. John Stacey writes that
... [preaching] has been seen as part of God's eternal action ...
as means of God speaking and acting in an almost totalitarian fashion
so that there is nothing more momentous and decisive than preaching
(Karl Barth) ... so that ... those who believe can be saved (Rudolf
Bultmann) ... as the essential action of the church, renewing its life
as it proclaims the kingdom (C H Dodd). [2]
Having said that, there have been a number of clear trends in
preaching since the eventful decade of the 1960s and the subsequent
domination of preaching by the mass media:
-
The sermon has remained an integral part of both Catholic and
Protestant worship in the West (in the East it has never had the
same pride of place). But it has become much less prominent. Sermons
are, by and large, much shorter than ever before. In some
congregations, the sermon is now often supported by
computer-generated graphics projected onto a screen. In more adventurous
types of worship a short homily may even be supported by brief
events such as a choreographed dance or short dramatic scetch.
-
In many churches, the sermon has taken on some of the
characteristics of entertainment. Huge congregations of many
thousands will listen to a preacher as he or she paces the stage and
strings together a number of biblical quotations and emotional
exhortations - interspersed by music and singing. The audience is
encouraged to respond through exclamation and movement. The emphasis
of such sermons is primarily to influence hearers. Teaching is a
relatively minor part of the preaching.
-
Tele-evangelists are those who pay large sums of money to buy
time on otherwise completely secular mass media. If the costs are
high, so are the potential financial rewards, for the sermons are
peppered with appeals for donations to fund the broadcasts. Analysts
of the style and content of these sermons tend to be somewhat
scathing about the tenuous connections between traditional
Christianity and their emotional and sometimes manipulative
contents.
-
A minority tends to altogether abandon or sideline sermons in
their traditional form. They maintain that the top-down nature of
the sermon is essentially paternalistic and that the average person
today prefers to negotiate meaning through discussion and sharing of
personal experience. The time given to sermons in the past is
replaced by group work after, or even during, worship sessions. This
format enshrines the traditional aims of combining teaching and
persuading through the medium of a sermon.
What of the future of preaching? Will it survive and strengthen as an
essential tool of the Church - or will it gradually succumb to the blast
of sounds and sights which increasingly unite the global community?
Only time will tell, of course. And the tides of cultural change are
extremely slow. Even now there is a large gap between the Western world
and the slowly awakening cultures of Africa. The latter may have to
first go through a phase of sermonising before it must face the
challenges which so stress Western Christianity in the 21st century.
Bishop John Spong has tried to envision a Church of the future [3].
He suggests that it will embody a number of characteristics which we can
now only glimpse on the cultural horizon:
-
There will be a shift from traditional theism to a more
world-focused, natural understanding of Jesus.
-
Guilt will no longer be used to persuade or drive people into the
arms of a protective body of the faithful. Instead the emphasis will
be on a corporate search for experienced truth and ethics based on
life rather than doctrine.
-
In place of ritualised worship and rites of passage will evolve a
caring, supportive community characterised by mutual acceptance
rather than tribal boundaries or exclusive claims.
If Spong is even moderately correct, the sermon is clearly going to
either disappear completely, or persist in a modified, attenuated form.
It will become more of a dialogue than a monologue. Preaching will have
to prove itself in a forum where hearers can and will contest a point or
deliver their own contradictory testimony.
In short, preaching is already in the workshop waiting to be
remodeled and reshaped into something radically unlike anything before.
___________________________________________________
[1] Quoted by Jerome Carcopino in Daily Life in
Ancient Rome, Penguin, 1964
[2] In A New Dictionary of Christian Theology, SCM Press, 1983
[3] A New Christianity For a New World, HarperSanFrancisco, 2002
[Home] [Back] |